Monday, 15 August 2011

Thoughts On War - Edmond De Goncourt In 1870

I am reading the diaries of Edmond and Jules de Goncourt just now. I have reached a stage in 1870 when Edmond is worriedly discoursing on the imminent victory of Prussia in the Franco-Prussian War during the siege of Paris in 1870. A characteristically poetic and poignant passage reads (my best translation which doesn't do full justice) :
' Monday, 28 November, 1870. Last night I was wakened by cannon fire. I went up to the upstairs room. In the sky there were little pockets of fire cut through by the the branches of the big trees. There was a chorus of firing from the fort at Bicentre all the way to the fort at Issy. A whole semicircle of explosions in the sky, lighting up like gaslight flares, followed  by thunderous echoes. Booming voices of death in the silence of the night. It stopped for a short time to be followed by the mournful howling of dogs mixed with the roaring cannon; tearful voices of people who had been awakened and were chattering, and cockerells crowing. Then cannons, dogs, cockerells, men and women all fell silent. Everything returned to silence. I held my ear to the window and all I could hear in the far distance was gunfire which sounded like the flat thump of an oar on the side of a wooden boat.' 
The diary entry goes on to describe the food-shortages and the terror and paranoia of a besieged and beleaguered population. It struck me that the fears and anguish of the people of Paris all those years ago have been echoed more recently in many war-torn households and neighbourhoods in Iraq, Afghanistan, Palestine, Libya, Syria, Bahrain...............

1 comment:

  1. Human beings are suppose to learn from their sins, and mistakes.
    Human beings are suppose to help their fellow man.

    The nature of the beast is to feed on the less fortunate.
    The beast thrives in chaos.
    The beast has no soul.

    We are beasts, not human beings.

    ReplyDelete