US Failure - By Amrullah Saleh

US has failed on main Afghan goals, ex-spy chief says

Reuters
(1 hour ago) Today

violence is at its worst across Afghanistan since the Taliban were ousted in 2001, with military and civilian casualties at record levels despite the presence of 150,000 foreign troops. — File Photo

KABUL: The United States had succeeded in establishing a government in Afghanistan but failed in crushing the Taliban and al Qaeda, a former Afghan intelligence chief who opposed plans to talk to insurgents has said.
Amrullah Saleh quit as President Hamid Karzai’s intelligence chief in June after disagreeing with Karzai over negotiating with the Taliban, a plan that this year has involved contacts with the insurgents but which Saleh labelled a disgrace.
US and NATO commanders have been talking up military successes since the last of an extra 30,000 US troops, ordered last December by President Barack Obama, arrived in summer and operations against insurgents were increased.
But violence is at its worst across Afghanistan since the Taliban were ousted in 2001, with military and civilian casualties at record levels despite the presence of 150,000 foreign troops.
“Americans had come to Afghanistan for three specific aims — defeating al Qaeda and annihilating the Taliban … and thirdly to help Afghans to create a powerful government,” Saleh told Afghanistan’s Tolo television in an interview.
“Al Qaeda is not crushed and the Taliban have turned again into a strategic threat,” he told the private station.
Western attention has focused on the process of withdrawing foreign forces after NATO leaders agreed in Lisbon last month that combat operations by NATO-led troops should end by 2014.
Obama is determined that U.S. troops will begin leaving by July 2011. Many analysts and observers say the increasingly unpopular war has gone badly for Washington, while European leaders are also under growing pressure to bring troops home.
With pressure growing for foreign forces to leave, attention has turned to the readiness of Afghan security forces to take over. Training, equipment and retention rates are major problems, leading some commanders to warn that Afghan forces are unlikely to be ready in time.
Western officials have long complained of endemic corruption in Karzai’s government, which they say weakens the state and stunts the growth of institutions like the armed forces, and it has long been a source of friction between Karzai and his Western allies.
Saleh, however, defended Karzai, saying sidelining him would be a mistake and would serve the interests of neither Afghans nor Americans. He should instead be strengthened, Saleh said.
Karzai has more recently come under fire in leaked US embassy cables, obtained by WikiLeaks, in which he was described as weak.
Saleh’s downbeat assessment of the war coincides with the findings of an Afghan-wide poll conducted by four major international media groups released this week.
It found Afghans were more pessimistic about the direction their country was taking, less confident in the ability of foreign troops to provide security, and more open to talks with the Taliban.
Saleh served in an alliance of factions that helped the United States overthrow the Taliban for harbouring al Qaeda leaders who plotted the the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks on the United States.
Long a critic of neighbouring Pakistan, Saleh said Pakistan’s meddling in Afghanistan and its support for the Taliban were among the main reasons the war was going badly.